Jump to content

Arturia Tape Mello-Fi FREE APD DEAL!


cclarry

Recommended Posts

I don't remember my reel-to-reel tapes ever sounding as bad as the factory presets in this Tape Distortion.  I'd get out my old reel-to-reel and try doing a comparison, but by now all my tapes probably have that nasty tape deterioration / degradation squeal. At least the ones I heard the last time I tried listening to some tapes had the squeal. Now, if these new-fangled imitation tape distortion FX plug-ins simulated varying degrees of that type of squeal, they would be more realistic than the distortion-I-never-had sound the contemporary plug-ins offer.

Maybe I should find a blank section of tape, record the squeal, and convert it into an IR.  🤪

A realistic reel-to-reel simulator should have several modes of mylar distortion (varying degrees of stretched tape all of which sound different, varying degrees of crumpled tape--including when it slides under the capstan and gets pulled by the take-up reel but still drags across the playback head, when the slightly stretched and twisted tape flips over for about 0.75 seconds before straightening out, etc.), as well as acetate tape artifacts such as a torn tape that either never got spliced or the splice came apart while playing back with the take-up reel spinning for a few seconds before the auto shut-off kicked in.

I can't be the only one that remembers the sounds of real tape artifacts!   🤪

Sorry to be so down about this plug-in.  Maybe its just that I'd rather have an FX plug-in--like yet another delay that sounds better than real delay ever did instead of a pretend effect that doesn't sound even half as good as the original artifacts.  This sounds like it was done by a junior high school DSP hacker who did a science fair project, not by a professional sound engineer.  🤪

On the other hand, its free!  🙂 

PS: I just dug out out the CHOW Tape Model Plug-in.  Even though it doesn't have the mylar and acetate artifacts, the CHOW version (also free) has more parameters to tweak to better "tune" the distortion tape to sound more realistic. For example, here's just one set of parameters ("Degrade").

image.png.b1652c636f76fd8db6d57dc48e9b4231.png 

 

Edited by User 905133
(2) to report on results from a comparison with CHOW Tape Model; (1) edits
Link to comment
Share on other sites

57 minutes ago, User 905133 said:

I don't remember my reel-to-reel tapes ever sounding as bad as the factory presets in this Tape Distortion.  I'd get out my old reel-to-reel and try doing a comparison, but by now all my tapes probably have that nasty tape deterioration / degradation squeal. At least the ones I heard the last time I tried listening to some tapes had the squeal. Now, if these new-fangled imitation tape distortion FX plug-ins simulated varying degrees of that type of squeal, they would be more realistic than the distortion-I-never-had sound the contemporary plug-ins offer.

Maybe I should find a blank section of tape, record the squeal, and convert it into an IR.  🤪

A realistic reel-to-reel simulator should have several modes of mylar distortion (varying degrees of stretched tape all of which sound different, varying degrees of crumpled tape--including when it slides under the capstan and gets pulled by the take-up reel but still drags across the playback head, when the slightly stretched and twisted tape flips over for about 0.75 seconds before straightening out, etc.), as well as acetate tape artifacts such as a torn tape that either never got spliced or the splice came apart while playing back with the take-up reel spinning for a few seconds before the auto shut-off kicked in.

I can't be the only one that remembers the sounds of real tape artifacts!   🤪

Sorry to be so down about this plug-in.  Maybe its just that I'd rather have an FX plug-in--like yet another delay that sounds better than real delay ever did instead of a pretend effect that doesn't sound even half as good as the original artifacts.  This sounds like it was done by a junior high school DSP hacker who did a science fair project, not by a professional sound engineer.  🤪

On the other hand, its free!  🙂 

PS: I just dug out out the CHOW Tape Model Plug-in.  Even though it doesn't have the mylar and acetate artifacts, the CHOW version (also free) has more parameters to tweak to better "tune" the distortion tape to sound more realistic. For example, here's just one set of parameters ("Degrade").

image.png.b1652c636f76fd8db6d57dc48e9b4231.png 

 

Kinda orange crayons to apple sauce here.

This is tape emu (and other) from a Mellotron, and intentionally more of the lofi vibe.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

An FX processor that can make any instrument sound like a Mellotron is cool in my book. :)

"The Mellotron, introduced in 1963, was a keyboard that had a tape playback mechanism under every key. Tape MELLO-FI’s sound and behavior is inspired by Mellotron V, our software recreation of this legendary instrument."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, abacab said:

An FX processor that can make any instrument sound like a Mellotron is cool in my book. :)

"The Mellotron, introduced in 1963, was a keyboard that had a tape playback mechanism under every key. Tape MELLO-FI’s sound and behavior is inspired by Mellotron V, our software recreation of this legendary instrument."

Very true!! I tried IK's Sampletron 2 with some of my own audio and thought it sounded more Mellotron "tapish" (or tape-like) than arturia did. But to its advantage, Mello-Fi works in real time (i.e., on live music as it is being played). 🙂  Sampletron 2's tapes need to dropped & dragged or loaded. So far as I can see there is no audio in to apply the tape FX.  😞 

Also, I remembered as I was shutting down last night, I forgot to mention arturia's "tape stop" FX.  That's a plus, but I think the Jr. H.S. hacker got a little help from a first-year college sibling who was home on spring break.  😜 

image.png

Edited by User 905133
(2) fixed typos; (1) to add an image of Sampletron's Tape Effects limited controls and to show the non-realtime "drag-and-drop" UI
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, e-cue said:

Kinda orange crayons to apple sauce here.

This is tape emu (and other) from a Mellotron, and intentionally more of the lofi vibe.  

I will agree that Mello-Fi can make audio sound like a 3" reel-to-reel tape deck.  Very crayonish tape emulation; not nuanced.

As for the Mellotron emulation, the factory samples on IK's Sampletron 2 sound much more "Mellotronish" both with and without IK's additional Tape Effects.

As for the orange crayons to apple sauce analogy, a free v. expensive comparison would be appropriate.

To be clear, the Mello-Fi factory presets do not make incoming audio sound Mellotronish.  As for sounding like Lo-Fi tape recordings, they are more caricatures. 

When I have a chance and more spare time than I have presently, I will dig out my under $100 7" reel-to-reel, some tapes, including some 3" reels done on an ancient first generation (I think) portable tape recorder (can't get more low fi than that) and assuming the mylar tapes  don't squeal and the acetate tapes aren't too brittle, I will make some samples and do a good faith attempt to use Mello-Fi to simulate realistic tape effects.  I could be wrong, but I think anyone with even a "tin ear" would be able to tell the difference.  

As I tend to do, if I am wrong, I will correct myself. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PS: I just found some genuine previously digitized low-fi recordings.  Though clearly not applicable to a purely Mellotron emulation plug-in, a seriously omnipresent effect plagued by many low-fi recordings is the low voltage battery effect.  Do any contemporary low-fi tape emulation plug-ins emulate this?

BTW, I did find an old digitization of a 3" reel and I agree that Mello-Fi could be used to simulate about 75-85% of that quality maybe more.  I was intentionally hyperbolic in saying that even someone with a tin ear could hear the difference.  Apologies to those who paid full price and are offended. I was intending to be humorous, not insulting.  In fact, I assumed that anyone who uses Cakewalk would be able to tell the difference.  

Edited by User 905133
fixed wording/typos
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...