Norfolk

Yes, chris.r, I know what you mean. There are always a lot of awkward things in big projects. Your organ example is very interesting! 30 controllers is a very difficult task! 3-4 is enough for me to have a lot of worries) In general, work with controllers is normally organized in Sonar. Of course, it would be better if instead of individual sticks there were full-fledged envelopes, but modern Sonar already has tools that allow you to conveniently work with the mouse and with sticks. Many people draw controllers with their hands, but now I think there should be complete tools for playing musicians. I am sure that the programmers are from Cakewalk can add the function of rewriting controllers separate. That would be enough for me. Updates are released regularly, I hope we will see this feature in the next ones.

chris.r, Thanks for participating! I was sure there was no problem here. I thought I didn't know something and someone would tell me which setting to enable. I have been working in Sonar for a long time since the 5th version, but I have always drawn midi-cc with my hands and a mouse. And now I write orchestral music, and now it's easier to play a part on the midi keyboard, and then edit what I need. Now I understand that Sonar can't do that at all. It seemed to me that this was some kind of very basic skill for DAW. In large projects, drawing with my hands and mouse becomes hard. Maybe the developers will hear us and organize this function?😉

msmcleod, thanks for the answer! You told a good way! But if I choose to use this method, I will have to completely abandon recording MIDI control events in a standard take lane. But, Sometimes I need to record MIDI events and MIDI control events at the same time, and then edit what I need Maybe there is a way to disable recording of MIDI control events and use only envelope automation? But even this will not be a very convenient way, i.e. the piano roll has a convenient section for editing controller parameters It would be very convenient to edit automation envelopes in Piano Roll View or to simply overwrite Midi concrols events only. I watched a video on working with Logic. It seemed to me that they have a very convenient implementation of this function. I would like it to be just as comfortable in my beloved Sonar

Guys, tell someone please. This question has tormented me for many years. The situation is this: We turn on the recording on the midi track, press the main record button [R], play the midi keyboard, we get something like this: Now I want to rewrite only automation, i.e. controllers, in this case a modulation wheel. I put "Sound on Sound" in the recording settings, turn on the recording. I get something like this: If you turn on playback afterwards, IN Kontakt, for example, will receive modulation wheel readings from both Take Lanes, i.e. both from the first recorded clip and from the second (and the controller will jerk wildly, trying to show everything that is ordered to it. Tell me how to organize such a recording? You just need to, if necessary, rewrite the necessary fragments of the controllers from the midi keyboard / controller, while leaving the midi notes in place, and edit the necessary places in the Piano Roll with the mouse. There are still Comping and Overwrite modes in the recording settings, but they do not give the desired effect. Thanks everyone for the answers!