Audio only working on Input 1 + Input 2 (1+2 S), but then only gets audio on one side.

[Jenna]

Hi everyone. 

I am using focusrite scarlett solo 3rd gen. 

Sound only comes from one side when I use (1+2S), when I switch it to Input 1 (1L), the green bar on the sides has equal levels, indicating that it is picking something up, however when I record there is no audio. When I switch it to Input 2 (2R), it comes up very minimally, however once I start recording the green bar completely disappears and I can't hear anything during playback. Everything else is fine, so I'm wondering if it could possibly be my mic? I'm using the Neewer NW-800. 

I've attached my settings as well. 

[sjoens]

How about a screenshot of your track input flyout?