Please Add Input Echo Button To PRV's Track Pane

[Keni]

Getting Old Having some tools unavailable in some views.... All should mean all!

 

In This situation, Changing MIDI Input Echo Enable while editing MIDI in PRV get old very fast back and forth between TV and PRV to continually switch this selection.... Elsewhere too!

Edited August 17, 2021 by Keni

[Xoo]

I'd also add that having it on a plug-in's toolbar (next to S/R/W widgets) would make a lot of sense (as would Mute there too!).

[Keni]

  On 8/17/2021 at 3:22 PM, Kevin Perry said:

I'd also add that having it on a plug-in's toolbar (next to S/R/W widgets) would make a lot of sense (as would Mute there too!).

Expand  

Such obvious prime need locations!

[Promidi]

Until the Bakers add this, maybe these workarounds might help.

Create a keyboard shortcut to Input Echo

Or

Assign "Input Echo" to a button on the custom console.

[Xoo]

Keyboard shortcut doesn't work if a plug-in has focus (I've tried already :-)).

[Will.]

  On 8/17/2021 at 10:54 PM, Kevin Perry said:

Keyboard shortcut doesn't work if a plug-in has focus

Expand  

This is one I cant get my head around.

[Promidi]

  On 8/17/2021 at 10:54 PM, Kevin Perry said:

Keyboard shortcut doesn't work if a plug-in has focus (I've tried already :-)).

Expand  

Keyboard shortcut works here (I use ALT + i) when a plugin has focus (I just tried it)...... and even if, with a particular plugin, it doesn't, there is always the custom console.

[Xoo]

OK - it sets IM on the track that has focus, which may not be the correct one (ie. the current plug-in).

[Keni]

  On 8/17/2021 at 10:29 PM, Promidi said:

Until the Bakers add this, maybe these workarounds might help.

Create a keyboard shortcut to Input Echo

Or

Assign "Input Echo" to a button on the custom console.

Expand  

Good Thought, but how do I tell it which instrument to enable when there are numerous (typical)

[David Baay]

For the PRV, doesn't 'Always Echo Current MIDI Track' address the need in the most common case that you just want to be able to play the instrument on the track you're currently editing?

[Keni]

  On 8/18/2021 at 6:15 AM, David Baay said:

For the PRV, doesn't 'Always Echo Current MIDI Track' address the need in the most common case that you just want to be able to play the instrument on the track you're currently editing?

Expand  

It would if I simply wanted it on all the time...

[Will.]

And also the ability to remove it from the track strips in Track Control Manager. 

[David Baay]

  On 8/18/2021 at 10:35 AM, Keni said:

It would if I simply wanted it on all the time...

Expand  

And you wouldn't want that because...?

[Keni]

I guess you haven’t run into the things I have. I only wish to transmit when I wish, not when I happen to have as current selection

[David Baay]

  On 8/18/2021 at 3:58 PM, Keni said:

I guess you haven’t run into the things I have. I only wish to transmit when I wish, not when I happen to have as current selection

Expand  

Actually, I generally feel the same way, and typically leave  'Always Echo' disabled. The main reason in my case is that I often leave Local Control enabled on my keyboard synth to eliminate the MIDI round-trip latency and get the best possible response when just playing and recording solo piano and not working with any other synths which is the way most of my projects start out. Obviously I don't want the MIDI track in my default template echoing automatically in that case.

But when working in a project with multiple synth tracks, and wanting to have the most transparent experience with performing on a controller while switching tracks in the PRV, I would think 'Always Echo' is the way to go. 

[Keni]

  On 8/18/2021 at 8:59 PM, David Baay said:

Actually, I generally feel the same way, and typically leave  'Always Echo' disabled. The main reason in my case is that I often leave Local Control enabled on my keyboard synth to eliminate the MIDI round-trip latency and get the best possible response when just playing and recording solo piano and not working with any other synths which is the way most of my projects start out. Obviously I don't want the MIDI track in my default template echoing automatically in that case.

But when working in a project with multiple synth tracks, and wanting to have the most transparent experience with performing on a controller while switching tracks in the PRV, I would think 'Always Echo' is the way to go. 

Expand  

I see your point, but adding the button would be more to my taste. We all have our work model preferences. Work arounds when needed, but I prefer.........