Jump to content

Is This Song any Good?


Keith Wilby

Recommended Posts

yes, it is great

excellent mix

nice base

great arrangement

I would only suggest some vocal automation

maybe pull back that synthy thing tat comes in around 2:10

 

otherwise

yes

it flies

count me as one who finds it as good as anything else

Edited by Jesse Screed
forgot something
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Keith, really good intresting melody, one never knows where its going untill it gets there , I think the synth`s (sax as well)let it down and cheapens what is a great song and the midi drums are not very nice (I use EZdrums 2) this is well worth finishing , its got so much going for it .. I didnt hear any guitar (Iwould say that being a guitarist) good vocal range, lots to play around with cheers P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Paul Bush said:

I think the synth`s (sax as well)let it down and cheapens what is a great song and the midi drums are not very nice

That's food for thought Paul, thank you. I'd be interested to know what you don't like about the drums - do you mean when the "loud" drums come in?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Keith Wilby said:

That's food for thought Paul, thank you. I'd be interested to know what you don't like about the drums - do you mean when the "loud" drums come in?

Straight off the bat its a great song Keith , I just didnt like the sound of the drums, its just my  personal taste  really  sorry , the melody really draws one in, so its all there , I´d be really  interested to see  what you`re going to do with it ...I´ll shut up now before i get myself into more trouble ..cheers P.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have to agree with Paul the drums are not great. They sound thin and mechanical, not at all like a real sounding kit, maybe that's what you are going for. I like the song but it has a pretty digitized mechanical feel to it.  What are you using for drums?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, horses for courses, I believe the saying goes? the real question is, do you think it's worth it? That personal muse provides all the answers you should ever need.

I've heard a number of your tunes here, and liked them all. Does it matter what a bunch of tossers think? Likely, not really, no. But you did graciously invite some critiques so I'd say for me, I found the musical parts and the arrangement very interesting, lots of great instrumentation choices, a hooky melody, with a lot of potential for mixing, and I think there is room in this world for this wonderful music!

I also thought the music was much, much more interesting than the lyrics. Your inventive song structure could be used to say something a little off the well-beaten "love" path? Something more powerful or opaque? Just a thought, worth what? Probably not that much.

If it is speaking to you, never mind the background noise, go straight at it.

 

cheers!

-Tom

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, PhonoBrainer said:

Well, horses for courses, I believe the saying goes? the real question is, do you think it's worth it? That personal muse provides all the answers you should ever need.

I've heard a number of your tunes here, and liked them all. Does it matter what a bunch of tossers think? Likely, not really, no. But you did graciously invite some critiques so I'd say for me, I found the musical parts and the arrangement very interesting, lots of great instrumentation choices, a hooky melody, with a lot of potential for mixing, and I think there is room in this world for this wonderful music!

I also thought the music was much, much more interesting than the lyrics. Your inventive song structure could be used to say something a little off the well-beaten "love" path? Something more powerful or opaque? Just a thought, worth what? Probably not that much.

If it is speaking to you, never mind the background noise, go straight at it.

 

cheers!

-Tom

Thanks Tom 😄

You know, I was just thinking the same thing about the lyrics and maybe that's what's stopping me from liking it unreservedly. They don't make an awful lot of sense for a start but I've had the song in my head for so long ...

I'll put me thinking cap on.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you have a lot of interesting material in this that can go in any direction.  I like the pallet of elements used.   2nd listen is telling me, Yeah.  I would cut the intro and ride with this horse to the end. No beating necessary. Nice gentle and soft beginning that builds and intensifies to a full gallop.

Lean into it.

Dean   

Edited by FreeEarCandy
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

First off - this is a cool song!  I think you should definitely continue to refine and improve the parts.

Nice vocal performance and overall arrangement is interesting.

I agree with the previous comments already expressed on the drums.  They do seem a little lacking.  It all comes

down to personal taste (of course) but I would look for samples that sound a little more nuanced and "Real".

I also agree that the lyrics could use more work.  They seem quite generic and could a more personal approach.

This is a great start.  In writing, almost all writers write a first draft to get ideas down.  The real work starts with

the 2nd draft, 3rd draft, etc.  --  where ideas are refined and changes are made.  These revisions happen many times before most authors

are happy with the finished product.  Keep Going!

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/7/2023 at 11:55 AM, Bajan Blue said:

why not EZDrummer all the way through?

It's a "quiet" kit at the start and I couldn't find a way of including two instances of EZD without crashing CbB so I opted for AD for the "loud" kit. Of course, this is potentially now all up in the air as I consider all of these useful comments so far 👍

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Keep it going. It has some really good aspects to it that are worth pursuing. Specifically, the interplay/choice of notes you have between the instruments. Don't hear too many songs that have the attention grabbing potential this one has. 🎶🎶🎶🎶

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...