Which of these soft guitars sounds more like a live instrument?

[Vyacheslav 2]

Hello!

Please help me choose! Which of these soft guitars sounds more like a live instrument? Pop-rock song.

Thank you in advance!

https://1drv.ms/f/s!AlLNG4SDVWiJgooEstC4FJk-nP5q5Q
1. exmpl01.mp3
2. exmpl02.mp3
3. exmpl03.mp3
4. exmpl04.mp3
5. exmpl05.mp3
6. exmpl06.mp3
7. exmpl07.mp3

Edited March 11, 2020 by Vyacheslav

[garybrun 594]

it depends on what sort of genre and track you are going to mix them in.
I like Nr 7 as the sound on its own but the others would cut through more in a larger mix.

To be honest they all sound artificial.

[geeare1 31]

i kinda liked ex 03 but what will work for your song depends more on the song and mix than my taste (or lack of taste). 

[AndyB01 143]

As a guitarist for over forty years I have to say that sadly the answer is: none of the above - they all sound thin and artificial. Sorry but no recommendations from me in that list.

Andy

[Vyacheslav 2]

Dear Andy! This riff, this song doesn't claim to be a Grammy. This is just a demo. ☺️

Please see the 8th example.

https://1drv.ms/f/s!AlLNG4SDVWiJgooEstC4FJk-nP5q5Q

[AndyB01 143]

11 hours ago, Vyacheslav said:

Dear Andy! This riff, this song doesn't claim to be a Grammy. This is just a demo. ☺️

Please see the 8th example.

https://1drv.ms/f/s!AlLNG4SDVWiJgooEstC4FJk-nP5q5Q

Fair enough , however the question you specifically asked was: "Which of these soft guitars sounds more like a live instrument?"

And the answer - IMHO - is none of them (inc #8). It's  just my opinion, if you don't agree, that's fine - we can agree to disagree. 

Andy